Wednesday, November 16, 2016

A review for the Sharp Swords & Sinister Spells RPG

Sharp Swords & Sinister Spells (SS&SS) is a "rules light sword and sorcery role playing game with Old School spirit", which is a very accurate description of this new RPG. It isn't a retroclone (maybe you could call it a “second” or “third generation” retroclone) but it does attempt to capture the general OSR feel and style (in fact, it borrows mechanics from others famous games, especially The Black Hack). My main interest with the SS&SS is because it is – as far as I know – the only OSR game published by brazilian authors in english. This review is based on the PDF offered through DriveThruRPG/RPGNow.


SS&SS's core mechanic is quite simple: roll a d20 against an Attribute. You succeed if roll equal or lower. This is like The Black Hack and it is an approach that I enjoy – simple and very easy to teach.

SS&SS also employs Usage Die (again from The Black Hack). The Usage Die is a clever mechanic used to keep track of ammo, food and other expandable resources. Basically, you roll a die and if you get a 1 or 2, that resource is spent. Otherwise, you just keep rolling.

SS&SS also uses Positive and Negative Dice, which is a just different name of D&D 5E's Advantage and Disadvantage mechanics (at the first, the new nomenclature caused a bit of confusion for me –  I thought it would be something like Shadow of the Demon Lord's Bane/Boon Die).

Other core mechanics is Pushing the Roll – a gambit mechanic where you ask for a second chance, but if you fail the referee can choose something particular nasty to happen to your PC. Again, simple and very easy to implement.

The last core mechanic is the Luck Roll. This mechanic is basically SS&SS's take on Luck Points/Attribute - it’s determined by the chosen Archetype (Class) and it works like Usage Die. It kinds of overlaps with the Pushing the Roll rule, although Luck offer a few twists to the PCs.

SS&SS uses 4 Attributes (generated by rolling 3d6): Physique, Agility, Intellect and Willpower; and 3 Archetypes (Classes): Warrior, Specialist and Magic User (cool, no Clerics!).

Each Archetype determines your Hit Dice (and thus Hit Points), Luck Die and Special Abilities.

The Archetypes' Special Abilities are iconic and seem to me be partly inspired by DCC RPG (like the Warrior's Improved Maneuvers, the Specialist's Luckiest of Them All and the Magic User's Blood Sacrifice). They are short, easy to use and just flavorful (in other words: I loved them).

After picking an Archetype, you must define your Vocation (for example, you're a Warrior with the Berserker Vocation or a Magic User with a Necromancer Vocation). Vocations are open-ended backgrounds/concepts that are used by the PCs to gain Positive Dice

The next step is rolling a Complication for your PC, which is a nice way to spice the character's background (in part explaining why you’re an adventurer). “Nice” stuff like been addicted to Sorcery, in debt to a corrupt noble or hunted by the Assassin's Guild. The cool part about Complications is that you can trigger them, once per session, to improve your Luck Die (in exchange, the referee is given free rein to place the Complication somewhere in your near/far future).

Weapons in SS&SS are simplified and divided in 3 categories. Armor reduce damage and shield (my favorite rule here) gives you a number of Negative Die to use on a roundly basis against attacks.

SS&SS has an interesting approach to Initiative. If I got it right, it's based on the Hit Dice size (which usually means Warriors go first). Ties are settled by an Agility checks. Agility also works as AC here, since armors reduce damage. SS&SS employs simple critical and fumble rules. Healing uses a Short/Long Rest dynamic. The game also uses a Powerful Enemy rule, also taken from The Black Hack.

Spellcasting in SS&SS requires a Willpower check. SS&SS has a simple but evocative rule for failing at spellcasting: the magic doesn’t work and the Magic User can choose between losing access to the spell for the day or not. If he chooses to keep the spell available, he suffers a complication devised by the GM. The book offers some guidelines, but this is by far may favorite part of SS&SS as it kind of allows you to run a "light version" of games like DCC RPG or Warhammer Fantasy. And yes, things get better (or should I see worse?): if the Magic User rolls a natural 20, he must check on a Spell Catastrophe table (sweet!).

SS&SS Spell List is short on description but more than enough for any referee running such light games. We're also offered guidelines on how magic item should work (and the price that PCs must pay to use them).

The next part deals with Opponents, with a short list of adversaries and basic rules for creating them (again we see a strong influence of The Black Hack).

Leveling Up is based on the number of adventurers survived and employs an Improvement Roll rule (can you guess from which game?).

SS&SS closes with an adventure generator appendix and a (very good looking) character sheet.

In end, SS&SS presents an interesting variant on The Black Hack, with more crunch and a stronger flavor toward Sword & Sorcery and Dark Fantasy. You can use it with minimum effort to run Warhammer Fantasy, DCC RPG adventures, Conan, Lankhmar, The Black Company and similar settings… I see myself using even for The Witcher and with minimal fuss it’s easily adaptable to other low magic genres, like Lord of the Rings.

Tuesday, November 15, 2016

Little Encounters – Of Aarakocra and Kenders (a 5E Monster Manual reading)

As I said in a previous post, I started to read “seriously” the 5E Monster Manual to get a better feeling of its implied setting. My issues with 5E are quite simple – I have none. However, 5E is my eternal “second choice” game. For example, I’m indulging like hell my Old School preferences right now – with DCC RPG. If I want something a little more “robust” (or I just want to please most of my players) the choice would be Pathfinder. If I want something different but still d20, I’d try 13th Age, Exemplars & Eidolons (or Red Tide, or Godbound), Beyond the Wall, Fantasy Craft, Iron Heroes, even Hackmaster. And if I really want the Old School I would go to AD&D 2nd, Rules Cyclopedia, OD&D etc. I just don’t have (so far) any use for my 5E books (to make things even crazier I even prefer the Playtest Versions of 5E rules and my favorite module still is Ghosts of Dragonspear Castle).

With the release of Volo’s Guide of Monsters (and Cubicle 7’s Adventurers inMiddle-Earth), I’m trying to give 5E a second chance. So I’m reading the Monster Manual and seeing what implied setting I can get from it. If I get any ideas about a particular critter I’ll post them here. Before that, it’s always cool to give direction to better (and more awesome) stuff along these lines. So, if you want a new approach to 5E Monster Manual, please, read this. I’m never gonna write something as good as that.
Cool art demands Race Stats for PCs!
OK… the first entry is about Aarakocra, those birdmen that I discovered back in the AD&D 2nd Monstrous Manual* and that are (visually) a lot more cool now. Aarakocra in 5E are flying humanoids from the Air Elemental Plane, servants of the Winds Dukes of Aaqa and so linked to the (short but evocative) Red of Seven Parts mythos. They’re neutral good creatures with a CR of ¼ (and racial enemies of gargoyles).
*Still the best Monster Manual ever; except, maybe, for some of those wonderful Planescape Monstrous Compendiums.

The Fiend Folio art was better.
Unfortunately, about Aarakocra, that’s all. Even with 5E concise and iconic description, there isn’t much here to really engage you. Ironically, the best part for me was the “kenderish” bit about Aarakocra not understanding concepts like material value, property or political borders (ownership I guess). I’m very inclined to a run a D&D-like game with shades of grey and a twist or two to the common tropes. Thus, I prefer adventures and encounters where the solution isn’t “Kill them all and take their stuff” (I’m already having a blast with my DCC RPG sessions, where the PCs are reavers, heretics and bastards of the best sort). The conclusion: I’ll use Aarakocra just to run an adventure instead of stablishing any concept for my 5E games. That’s why I made this post a Little Encounter.

Fortunately no Kenders here.

The Dwellers in the Storm (a adventure seed for 1st-4th level PCs)

I’d keep Aarakocra as natives of the Air Elemental Plane with a twist: in order to reproduce, their eggs must hatch in the Material Plane (otherwise, they either don’t hatch or strange air half-spirits are born instead of Aarakocra). So, the Aarakocra keep secret eyries in the Material Planes, close to portals to the Air Elemental Plane. In the particular mountain range where the PCs are, the portal is the eye of a cyclical storm.

The humans (or dwarves or whatever common humanoid civilized race you’re using) are colonizing the mountain range and cleaning it of “monsters” in order to mine precious metals and gems. Because Aarakocra don’t understand the very concept of ownership, they’re a constant nuisance to the local towns, flying down and “stealing” stuff (mostly objects for which they’re curious).

The problem starts when the Aarakocra eggs go missing. The birdmen get more aggressive in their searches. They don’t blame the humans but – remember – they also don’t respect property and probably privacy. They’re now invading houses, taverns, deposits etc. Things are getting violent.

The PCs are hired to kill or otherwise get rid of the damn birdmen. This can be accomplished quite easily if they manage to climb the eyrie. The Aarakocra are many but hardly violent. However, if the Aarakocra are simply destroyed, the cyclic portal to the Air Elemental Plane will become uncontrollable and the next storms will be catastrophic (with massive amounts of air elementals released, probably dislodging dangerous beings that live at the mountain tops… things like giants, dragons and flying krakens**, which will probably banish any humanoid presence in the region).
**Probably the only thing I ever liked about Forgotten Realms 4E.

Unfortunately no flying krakerns... but who knows!
If the PCs are smart (or just diplomatic) they can discover about the Aarakocra’s eggs and start investigating. The culprit will probably be a flying or teleporting thief. I would use a high-level wizard with a flair for drama (he leaves a rune behind to mark his daring thefts). This wizard is a high-level menace and can be easily tracked. However, it’d be suicide to face the magic user in battle. No problem, he won’t mind telling the party that he was hired by a very rude merchant from one of the towns that were attacked (the merchant was rude and arrogant, but paid well).

The merchant in question is indeed very rich but can be faced by the party. He discovered that Aarakocra eggs are worth (flying bodyguards are useful). He also believes that by stealing the eggs will destroy the local eyrie. He doesn’t know (or believes) in portals to other dimensions and such. Actually, you can create a merchant that isn’t a “capitalist greed-driven evil schemer” cliché and even establish that he’s really trying to improve the region and end the “birdmen menace”.

The problem about facing the merchant is that – until the eggs’ theft is proved – he has the law by his side (the town guard, the sheriff and maybe even a paladin if you’re feeling mean). If the party can sneak into the merchant’s caravan/deposit/mansion/secret evil base and get the eggs everything is fine. You can even add a timer to the adventure, by implying that the Aarakocra will unleash a particularly big air elemental against the local towns if the eggs aren’t found (or after two or three Aarakocra are killed searching for the eggs).

OK. Drama set. What are the rewards? (Because just saying “You saved the region and avoided a war” is boring).

1. The local towns will see and treat the PCs as heroes (or maybe as villains, if the Aarakocra end the adventure causing too much trouble and the PCs back them up).
2. Now, the real reward is that if the PCs play fairly with the birdmen they’ll have gained some interesting contacts and treasure:
- The Aarakocra are now their allies and the party has safe (aerial) travel through the entire mountain range, with access to places before deemed unreachable or too costly to go (i.e. insert adventure hooks here).
- Aarakocra don’t care/understand property and treasure. While this means that the party can lose an item or two, they also have access to the Aarakocra lairs, where they can pick a lot of useful stuff that is just lying around (gems and items that the Aarakocra found scattered all over the region).
- If the PCs were really diplomatic and impressed the Aarakocra I would let the birdmen teach them their cool Dragonball-like dance for summoning air elementals (besides teaching the PCs the air elemental language). This is the kind if unique and special reward that I really enjoy in adventures (and that games like DCC RPG encourage a lot).

Your new flying friends can get you there!

Friday, November 11, 2016

Thanagarian – a new DCC RPG class!

Thanagarians are a proud and militaristic race of winged humanoids from the planet Thanagar. They once worshiped the dread Great Old Ones, entities from the Void whose dreams (it’s believed) brought forth the powers of Law and Chaos that today battle over the Multiverse.

At the dawn of it’s history, Thanagar was a harsh world with a primitive and savage culture. The envoys of the Great Old Ones, specially the Starspawns of Great Cthulhu, gave the Thanagarians the learnings of agriculture, mathematics, and philosophy — the foundations of their entire culture. The Starspawns, however, also enslaved the Thanagarians, using them as pawns in battles across the Void and the nascent champions of Law and Chaos.

As they matured, however, the Thanagarians rebelled against the Starspawns. Their knowledge of the Great Old Ones was used in the creation of special weapons, effective against the ilk of Azathoth. For this reason, their Nth metal weapons have mystical properties and can work against otherwise invulnerable creatures, like supernatural and extradimensional entities.

Many lone Thanagarian warriors roam the stars and the Multiverse, hunting for signs of the Great Old Ones, particularly Cthulhu and his kind.


The Thanagarian Class

Hit points: d10.

Attacks: +1/level.

Action Dice: as a Warrior.

Crit Die/Table: as a Warrior.

Saves: as an Elf.

Weapon training: A Thanagarian is trained in the use of these weapons: battleaxe, club, crossbow, dagger, dart, flail handaxe, javelin, lance, longbow, longsword, mace, polearm, shortbow, short sword, sling, spear, staff, two-handed sword, and warhammer. Thanagarians also know how to operate futuristic weaponry, at the Judge’s discretion (ray guns for example). All Thanagarians know to use and repair their special Nth Metal weapons. Thanagarians only use armor specially adapted and that won’t affect their speed (heavier armors are usually made from Nth Metal).

Bow to no Higher Power: After their pacts with the Great Old Ones, the Thanagarians bow to no god, immortal, fiend or patron. When healed by a cleric’s Lay on Hand, Thanagarians are always treated as of the Opposed Alignment.

Hawkmen: Thanagarians can fly with at a speed of 40 feet if they’re not burdened by cumbersome armor or weight. The Judge should use common sense here, but generally most Thanagarians, if unencumbered and with standard strength, can carry another humanoid of similar size or smaller for shorts periods of time (or glide down with something heavier to avoid fall damage). Thanagarians need lots of space for flying, so only under open skis, (really) big complexes or the vast underworld vaults of the depths would their wings be of use. Flying isn’t the same as walking though. Thanagarians must spend one Action Dice to fly. However, once in the air, Thanagarians can execute a special diving attack. This works exactly as a charge (see the Core Book at page 96) and requires just one Action Die. So, Thanagarians with 2 or more Action Die, that are already flying, can execute a flying-by attack, by spend their first Action Dice to dive and the second Action Dice to fly away from their enemy. This maneuver is an exception to normal Withdrawal rules (see the Core Book at page 96) – in other words, a Thanagarian can execute a flying-by attack without suffering a free attack from the target.

Nth Metal Weaponry: Thanagarians start the game with one Nth Metal weapon of their choice. This special metal is manufactured with high-level technology. The Nth Metal has electrical and gravitational properties and can even disrupt magical energies. Nth metal weapon are also lighter than traditional metal weapons and practically unbreakable. They can wound any supernatural creature, extraplanar entity or spirit, corporeal or not. Finally, Nth metal weapon are anti-magic. Each time a Thanagarian hits a target, the Nth metal weapon simultaneously delivers a special dispel magic effect, like the 16-17 result of the same spell (see the Core Book at page 208). The Thanagarian must roll 1d20 + character level + Strength modifier to determine the target’s Will save to resist the dispel. If the Thanagarian rolls a natural 1, his weapon overcharges and can’t be used for 1d6 rounds. Thanagarians can burn Intelligence to increase the dispel check. Each point spent grants a +2 bonus. Points thus burned recover naturally. Thanagarians can also use their Nth metal weapon to counterspell any effect thrown at 20 feet of them. This follow the normal spell duel rules, but a Thanagarian is limited to use dispelling proprieties of his Nth metal weapon.

Favored Enemy: Cthulhu!
Magic Slayers: Thanagarians are taught to resist and fight magic. This has benefits and small drawback. The good part is that Thanagarians can burn Intelligence to gain a bonus on saves against magical effects. They also add their character level to damage rolls against spellcasters and supernatural creatures. Finally, because of their innate distrust of magic, Thanagarians must spend 1 Luck points each time they’re targeted by a beneficial magical effect, like healing. If the Thanagarian can’t or won’t spend Luck, he must save to resist the effect.

Advanced Race: Thanagarians know technology are usually able to understand the basic proprieties or functions of any technological device found, at the Judge’s discretion.

Luck: Thanagarians add their Luck modifiers to their initiative rolls and to any check dealing with fly. 

Thursday, November 10, 2016

What I want to post in the following weeks...

I’m amazed to see that I got three posts in a month. This isn’t because I’m having any free time (quite the contrary) but mostly because posting stuff here is cheaper than therapy. So, what am I going to do now? I have a few things in mind to finish:

1.  For DCC RPG I’m creating a Thanagarian Class. More accurately, I’m creating the one type of Thanagarian that I know and love – those dudes from the awesome Justice League cartoon in the 90’s. Besides being pulpy (Flash Gordon!), the idea of “alien flying warriors with anti-magic technology that fights Cthulhu Mythos” is just so cool and metal that I feel obliged to create it for my DCC campaign (which is almost certainly to suffer an alien invasion given the consequences of a nasty and evil-minded PC wizard).

Favored Enemy: Cthulhu!
I believe news classes should often have unique mechanics or new ways of approaching the game, so I want to find a proper niche for my Hawkmen (the ability to fly is surely one). Similarly, I also have ideas for an Imp/Goblin/Gnome class and for a Martial Artist class – both using new rules, instead of being combination of previous classes.

This is my "gnome" class for DCC RPG. A slave/servant caste of the Elves.
2.  I’m a late comer to D&D 5E. I mean, I read it and run it for my players during the Playtest Packs and I even did a few one-shots, but unfortunately 5E is my eternal “second option” for fantasy games (the blame is mostly on DCC RPG). I always gravitate to other games (today DCC, but I’m equally tempted by 13th Age or just to return to Pathfinder and older D&D editions). I think that the solution to my “problem” with 5E follows similar issues that I have with 4E. I was never satisfied with my 4E games until I decided that I should create a homebrew built upon 4E’s idiosyncrasies. I believe that this was one of the main problems with 4E – the lack of a new setting that showed its strengths (like Eberron did for 3E).

I’ll try to create something for 5E. To accomplish this I started reading the Monster Manual to get the general feel of the “implied setting”. I think I’ll post my ideas here. Let’s see if this will work out.

They should have done a full setting with Nerath.
3.  Now, for Pathinder. First, a want to finish my Mastermind class. I’m a little obsessed with the idea of a “Tyrion Lannister/Sherlock Holmes” class: a PC class that is “brains over brawn” (check here to see my first attempt, for OD&D).

The Mastermind should be generic enough to fit concepts like sages, master spies, courtesans, tacticians, mountebanks etc. The Mastermind’s focus should be intellectual/social/party support, without resorting to magic to accomplish any of those goals (I want to stay away from classes like the Investigator).  Although I have Paizo’s Ultimate Intrigue I’m avoiding reading it until I finish the Mastermind.


4.  Again for Pathinder. The more I read d20 based RPGs the stronger my belief that races shouldn’t give bonuses/penalties to Ability Scores.

The way most d20 games treat ability scores these days I don’t think that race should modify it. By avoiding tampering with Ability Scores, you can keep the game mechanically simple and maybe more balanced. I believe that race should give you a list of racial benefits and disadvantages, some of which would be mandatory (a basic set of traits for 1st level PCs) and other that are optional or available at higher levels. In fact, I think that races should be represented mechanically as list of options you can choose along the character advancement (if you read Dawnforge you may have seen a similar approach, but I want something lighter). By providing a more open-ended approach to races and the opportunity to get new racial traits during advancement, maybe I can keep races interesting and meaningful during the entire game instead of just at the first levels.



OK. Now let’s go back to work.

Sunday, November 6, 2016

A review on dK2 System - a generic french d20

OK, I need to practice my (considerably poor) French skills. So, let’s take a look at an interesting take on the d20 made by Éditions John Doe, called dK2 System. This review is based on the PDF version.



dK2 System is a generic and simplified version of d20 that brings a number of cool ideas to the table. dK2 is geared toward a cinematic style, with considerable less crunch than your usual d20. The game only uses d20s and d6s, working as a toolkit (for example, while it’s presented as level-based, it also shows you how to remove level). In fact, the dK2 System is practically an effect-based d20 system, with a goal of reducing the GM’s work.

The basic check is like other d20 games – roll a d20 + plus modifiers against a target number. The target numbers start at 5 and usually go all the way up to Impossible at 40. The standard TN is 15.

Almost everything in the dK2 is divided in 3 categories: amateur, professional and “brutasse” (brute?). The best use of this abstraction is with equipment – instead of long lists of weapon, armor and general items, you’re taught how to “build” an item with those 3 categories. For example: anyone in dK2 can use amateur weapons, which are usually light and deal 1d6 damage. Professional weapons are heavier and deal 2d6, while brute weapons deal 3d6 – to be proficient in their use you must buy the correspondent Assets (these are like Feats).

Another special rule are the Krasse die or dK. This is a d6 used for a lot of situations in the system. The Krasse die only has 2 results – 3 (or half-Krasse) and 6 (or Krasse). All other numbers are ignored. Krasse work in certain aspects like Action Points from D&D or even Fate Points from FATE. They are special modifiers and a metagame currency, behaving like a karma mechanic.

For example, let’s say your elven ranger PC wants to try a particular tricky shot to disarm that orc holding the princess hostage. Instead of just providing a TN, the GM can rule that the stress of the situation, the wind and even the orc’s own movements can either help or hinder the elf’s shoot. So the GM provides a basic TN (let’s say 15) plus 3 Krasse die of difficulty. The GM will roll 3d6 and add any ‘3’ or ‘6’ that come up to the basic 15. Now comes the cool part: after this check, all Krasse die are added to the party’s pool of Krasse, to be used freely. In this aspect, Krasse works like a karma mechanic and reinforce the system’s cinematic feel (the more risk the party accept, the more bonus they get).

Krasse die are certainly the system’s best feature, although they have a weird use called Circumstance Krasse. These are – if I understood them correctly – innate modifiers applied to certain checks where the Krasse die aren’t later added to the party’s pool. I prefer to ignore Circumstance Krasse and just use a higher TN, as I believe this rule breaks the game’s purposed flavor.

OK. Moving on.

All PCs in dK2 system are made of Characteristics, Advantages, Competences, Assets, Counters and Equipment.

Characteristics are like D&D Abilities (the usual six – STR, DEX, CON, INT, WIS and CHAR – although the game encourages you to rename them to better suit your campaign). Like True20, the dK2 System uses only modifiers, with +1 been the standard stat for humans. The Characteristics are generated through distribution (usually 0, +1, +2, +3, +4 and +5) or by spending points.

Advantages are divided in Attack (STR + INT), Defense (DEX + CHAR) and Saving Throw (CON + WIS).

Competences are Skills and you usually start with your INT + 6 ranks to distribute. Each Competence modifier is made of two Characteristics plus ranks. For example: Athletics uses STR and DEX, while Initiative uses DEX + WIS.

For a system geared toward generic and cinematographic action, I find dK2’s Competence rules a bit harsh. You must have at least 1 rank in a Competence to add the relevant pair of Characteristics. If you have 0 ranks, you just roll a pure d20. Here I’m inclined of adding a house rule: if you have no ranks in a Competence, and a unskilled PC could reasonably use it, just add the two Characteristics and divided it by half.

Competences are another part where dK2 shows new ideas for skills. Reputations (WIS + CHAR) and Resources (INT + WIS) are treated as Competences, which is really nice because it allows you to build characters around two famous archetypes: the rich PC and the well-connected PC (or both).

My favorite Competence is Preparation (INT + CHAR). This skill was the main inspiration for my Mastermind’s and Sage’s The Right Tool for The Job class feature. It basically allows you to buy stuff “retrospectively” (i.e. during the adventure), justifying it by saying that your PC “obviously” came prepared for a particular situation or challenge (“Of course I brought more rope! Did you really believe that I would enter the Orc Pits without 300 feet of rope?”).

Another important bit about Competences is that you can use a skill in dK2 to “habilitate” another check (“Habiller un jet”). The idea is that, if you can explain how a certain Competence can help you with another check, you spend 1d6 Energy Points and gain a bonus to your check (+1 for every two ranks in a Competence). It’s the same idea of D&D 3rd synergy bonus, but with a more active and interesting take.

Counters are divided between Hit Points (10 + CON) and Energy Points (10 + WIS). Energy Points work as mental health, mana and willpower (very similar to BESM d20 if I’m not mistaken).

Assets are a mix of racial and class features (including weapon and armor proficiency), besides feats. They’re everything that makes a character unique and customizable. dK2 System took a design step that I always felt right for d20: upgrading Feats to be the system’s basic building block for PCs.

Assets are divided in various groups: Origin Assets deal with race, culture and innate gifts; Development Assets are how dK2 deals with PCs advancement (level-based or not); we also have Combat Assets (no further explanations required); Adventurous Assets, which are a general category covering background, profession, action knacks, special equipment, sidekicks, organization links etc.; and finally Magic Assets, which can represent anything, from wizardry and clerical magic to psi and supers. There’re also Assets for things like vehicles, which is really nice.

Among the Racial Assets we have rules for Humans, Elves, Dwarves, Gnomes, Halflings, what I believe to be Satyrs, Hounedin (Dogfolk I guess), Kitling (Catfolk), a kind of Half-Giant, Ogres, Orcs, a small goblinoid/kobold/fey race, Deep Ones/Sahuagin, Trolls and steam-powered Golems.

Magic in dK2 System uses a general effect table, where you build your spell/miracle/psi power “on the fly” by choosing a set of traits (range, damage, etc.), making a Competence check and spending Magic Points.

To cast an effect, you must also use a domain (air, fire, body, divination etc.) and a style (sorcery, clergy, psi etc.). There’re guidelines for various classical effects and even a variant for memorizing spells, like traditional D&D.

The magic system also uses what’s called “Factor D” (or FD) to determine a spell’s TN. FD is basically dK2’s take on Challenge Rating/Hit Dice. However, they greatly expanded the concept, using it to cover a lot of effects – from basic TN to monster statistics. It’s another excellent idea.

Finally, we arrive at Equipment, which is a short section due to dK2’s abstract design that divide everything the amateur, professional and brute categories (which I find really helpful as I’m a bit tired of reading through normal equipment list in most games).

Combat in dK2 System is easy to follow and traditional. Initiative is rolled and then everyone takes their actions. Attacks can be defended with a reaction, through a contested check. If you’re hit, armor reduces damage.

Things start to change once you hit 0 hit points. There is no negative HP in dK2. Once at 0 hit points, your PC loses the ability of using Krasse die. Besides that, after reaching 0 HPs, each time your PC rolls a natural 1 or an adversary get a 6 on a Krasse dice, you must save versus death and (if your survive) roll on a critical table to determine your PC’s penalties and wound effects. The same idea is true for Energy Points, which works more like a Willpower/Sanity/Mental Pool.

Recovery in dK2 is relatively easy, but it’s also limited by “recuperation points” (after spending them, the only way to recover is natural healing). Due to dK2 System toolkit approach, the damage/wounding rules are also customizable for each campaign, although the system really works best for heroic and cinematic stories.

Social relations also get their own rules, which I found a little weird. Instead of using a simple check, like must d20 games, dK2 ‘System creates what seems at first a mini-social combat system, where you must succeed at a social check before rolling “damage” (which determines how hard it is for the target to resist your persuasion/intimidation/seduction etc.). The entire thing looks a bit unnecessary as written (if the authors wanted to push in this direction, I’d have preferred either a more robust system). The way the rules are written, I see a high “whiff factor” (you can roll really good at your “social” attack, but then rolls terrible at “social” damage… and the target only needs to succeed in either check to completely negate your action).

We have reached by now a little more than half through the book (my version of dK2 is a 129 pages PDF). The rest of dK2 is dedicated to what is called dKrunch – a set of optional and modular rules, to be added as desired by the GM.

Combat gets a lot more detail, including rules for fire arms, explosive damage (where rolling a certain number allows you to roll and add additional die), scale rules and even a mass combat system. We also get rules for diseases, environmental damage and other traditional stuff. dKrunch also provides rules for crafting, cybernetics, besides further details for contacts, reputation, resources and organizations.

The next section gives you templates for various classical campaigns, by providing Advantages, Competences and Asset lists for fantasy or modern games, for example. The book ends with a few articles detailing general miscellaneous subjects: like using the famous E6 subsystem in dK2, substituting d20s for 2d10 or 3d6 (and its consequences), more complexes checks (to increase drama or tension) etc.

dK2 is an excellent evolution of d20, perfect for groups that want less work, but don’t desire something so light as Microlite, Simple20 or Basic d20. dK System is lighter than Tru20 and d20 Modern (and a lot simpler than BESM d20). Its level of crunch is probably a bit below Savage Worlds. It’s really generic but focused on heroic games (again, kind like Savage Worlds and maybe FATE). However, its degree of abstraction may not satisfy those players/GMs that prefer more details and tactics.

Friday, November 4, 2016

The Princes of Dale (my OD&D one-shot for The Hobbit)

After moving to my current city I was greatly influenced by the local Gamemaster style at running games, especially in regard to his DIY attitude. In fact, we’re currently having a blast at his 2d20 campaigns – first Conan, now Mutant Chronicles (2d20 is an awesome system about which I hope to post more in the future). You just have to see my GM’s FATE variants and his character sheet in general to get an idea of how cool they are. So, based on a that I tried to run a one-shot of Hobbit but never go around to use it (in part because I discovered later that 90% of the local player base hate one-shots).

The idea started after posting my Burrows & Dragons variant for Swords & Wizardry. I really wanted to run a game that used 74's OD&D, but with a better graphic presentation and maybe even using the Chainmail rules for combat. Unfortunately I meet this excellent OD&D variant where your number of attacks scale with level (but keeping OD&D damage simplicity) and ditched Chainmail for a later occasion.

The one-shot was to be called ‘Princes of Dale’. The PCs were all famous adventurers of Dale. One of them really is the Prince of Dale, grandson of Bard Dragonslayer, coming back from a campaign in the East. Another is the daughter of Thranduil, who left her father’s Woodland Realm to prove herself; a third is the Heir of Erebor, Thorin III “Stonehelm”. The fourth is a lesser Istari who lost his fire magic battling an cold drake centuries ago (and who believes that the Fire Ring should have belonged to him). I also created a fifth character, a hobbit from the Took family, but never got to make his character sheet, because I realized no one would want to play with a hobbit (annoying, I know…).

The idea for the one-shot was that the party would meet secretly at the new Laketown, during nightfall, to brave the fearful ruins where Smaug fell some many years ago. Each character would have a personal goal – the lesser Istari wanted to find any remain dragonfire to regain his magic; the elven princess wanted the Black Arrow itself etc.

The system was basically a reskinned OD&D with a more abstract notion of Hit Points (who are treated here also as Morale), rules like ‘Shields shall be splintered!’ and other stuff I made (besides things like using ‘Combat That Scales’). I didn’t used Ability Scores (they’re practically unnecessary in OD&D). Checks that deal with Ability Scores would be solved by rolling 3d6 most of the time against a TN of 9 or 10 (can’t remember) or 4d6 if thing were difficult (and 2d6 for easy tasks, or things a character should be good, like dexterity for elves and constitution checks for dwarves).

Here’re are the character sheet (they're in portuguese). I tried to be minimalist in design (and OD&D is itself some very light rules system).




Thursday, November 3, 2016

Using Roles in Pathfinder (and maybe in other D&Ds)

Yes, I’m still alive (sort of...). Because of Real Life threats of extremely high Challenge Rating (like the Job! or the dreaded Certification Exams!) I was forced to decide to use my spare time wisely, so I’m using it to run a hilarious and deadly DCC RPG campaign every 15-20 days instead of blogging (sorry). However, I’m still sketching stuff and I hope to post some here, like this small idea.

When the D&D Next/5E open playtest started, you theoretically built a character by choosing a race, a class, a background…

… and a theme.

It was weird but I rather like it. At the time backgrounds were basically skill groups to ground your character in the fantasy setting society (Soldier, Acolyte, Craftsman etc.). Themes were something more nebulous. Sometimes they worked like Feats, other time as narrative/flavor abilities.

Breaking expectations: here we have a Leader, a Defender, a Controller and a Striker.

The examples I can remember now are Slayer, Guardian and Sage.

Slayer – I think – allowed you to deal damage equal to your Str modifier even if you missed (something taken from D&D 4E I guess). Guardian allowed you to protect someone adjacent by inflicting Disadvantage (roll twice, pick the worst result) to the enemy’s strike. Sage was really original and cool, if you character failed a lore check, you didn’t get the information but you knew someone (or someplace) who has it.

It’s easy to see now that Themes were too different and so they’re mixed with Backgrounds so that in the final D&D 5E a Background would give you a social grounding, a few skills, equipment and a narrative advantage (besides other stuff).
However, like I said, I enjoyed Themes. The fact that you could create, for example, a Wizard Slayer or a Fighter Sage were things that I very much appreciated. Themes could create really different characters, although the mechanic was still a little off.
So, a few months ago I thought that maybe what I was looking was not Themes, but at Roles (yup, from D&D 4E).
What if every character in Pathfinder/D&D (every edition except 4E and 5E) were made of race, class and role? Roles here would be something completely separated from class (unlike 4E).
It’s just a random thought but see if you can find anything useful in this madness. The mechanics below were made thinking about Pathfinder and they give a little boost to PCs (but I believe you can place them in other editions).

Character Roles:

The Striker: You’re the one responsible for dealing damage. Once per round you can roll damage twice and pick the best result.

The Defender: You’re the shield of the party. At any time, once per round, you can become the target of any attack against an adjacent ally.

The Controller: You’re the strategist and battlefield master. At any time, you can give Disadvantage to one NPC check or force one NPC to choose between moving or acting (in Pathfinder terms you can negate one Move Action). You can’t use this ability two rounds consecutively.

The Leader: You’re the heart of the party. At any time, you can give Advantage to one PC or allied NPC check. You can’t use this ability two rounds consecutively.

Please note that these abilities are purposely abstract/generic. It falls to the player to described how his character use a Role’s ability (easy for Strikes, but Leaders and Controllers will have to describe their Role’s effects with a little more effourt… a Wizard Controller could launch a lesser magic dart, slowing an enemy; while a Fighter Controller could throw a small knife or maybe even the head of that goblin he just killed).


Until next!

Damnit Thranduil, you blinked again!